Tom Saviello: CMP’s incompetence put Maine’s clean energy at risk

Lewiston Sun Journal

Imagine you decided to buy an electric car. You scoped out all your options and picked one. You check with Central Maine Power (CMP) on how much extra money you would need to spend to make sure the outlet at your house is adequate to charge the vehicle. CMP tells you “No problem, your connection is adequate.” So, you go to the bank, get your loan and buy the car.

Upon returning home you get a call from CMP. You think they are calling to say congratulations on doing your small part to reduce climate change. Instead, CMP says “We made a mistake; your fixture cannot safely handle this new demand. You need to pay us an undetermined amount of money to make upgrades, and we don’t know how long this upgrade will take.”

You are totally disillusioned. The extra cost CMP wants to charge you stops your small, but important effort to impact climate change. 

Well, CMP recently did just that to Maine’s solar industry.

This industry has been developing projects at more than 100 substations across CMP’s territory. After signing contracts with CMP and entering into formal agreements, many of these developers made down payments to the tune of hundreds of thousands of dollars. Still other companies, relying on the fact that CMP actually understands their infrastructure, constructed solar farms worth tens of millions of dollars. They, like your electric car, are ready to “plug” in to the substation. But CMP is now saying “Oops, we made a mistake, the substation upgrades you funded for this project actually weren’t adequate to meet our standards, so you have to pay more money or we won’t allow you to connect to our customers.”

How much money do you ask? CMP’s miscalculations could cost the solar industry over $100 million dollars. In some cases, according to estimates by solar developers, the increased cost could be more than the total cost of the total facility.

It may very well shutter projects that would add electricity to the grid at a much lower cost than the power they want to deliver on their unpopular New England Clean Energy Connect project (NECEC corridor) providing electricity to Massachusetts. According to the PUC, a number of these projects would only charge 3.5 cents per kilowatt-hour, or about 50% on the ratepayer’s monthly electric bill.

This, along with thousands of jobs and an estimated $500 million investment in Maine could all be lost, thanks to Spanish-owned CMP’s incompetency.

Unfortunately, this new development is shocking, but it isn’t surprising. This is, after all, the Spanish company that cannot get their billing straight. They have smart meters that are “dumb.” They’ve had over 20 major outages last year alone. They sent illegal shut off notices; AND for the last three years has ranked last among power utilities by JD Powers. Nobody can trust them!

In Maine’s Climate Council Report Governor Mills wrote “Maine can’t wait to strengthen our economy by investing in renewable-energy infrastructure and providing good-paying jobs in clean energy and energy efficiency.” The ambitious goals to increase renewable energy set by the Governor cannot be met.

The Clean Energy Economy Report noted “In June 2019, Governor Mills signed legislation into law increasing the state’s Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS) from 40 percent to 80 percent by 2030 and setting a goal of 100 percent renewable electricity by 2050. Maine’s new RPS obligation is considered one of the most ambitious in the country and certainly reflects the most ambitious 2030 target in New England.”

This same report said” Solar development, both utility scale and smaller distributed energy generation, present economic development opportunities. These projects can provide various benefits to their host communities, provide energy cost savings, develop community solar projects with cost savings to project subscribers, and create cost savings to taxpayers through municipal or state projects.”

It’s safe to say these investments cannot be met with Maine solar development blown off course by a foreign corporation that can’t, or won’t, stay true to their word.

Finally, CMP acts as if this capacity issue is a new problem. It is not. Maybe we would not be here today if CMP focused on bringing their Maine infrastructure into the 21st century instead of constructing the New England Clean Energy Connect. CMP is more interested in using Maine as an extension cord to make billions off a contract between Massachusetts and Hydro-Quebec than providing reliable service to their existing customers right here in Maine.

It is time for CMP to clean up their act, keep their promises, and fix their many problems. 

 

MaineWontWait_December2020_printable_12.1.20.pdf

StrengtheningMainesCleanEnergyEconomy_Nov92020.pdf

Showing 4 reactions

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.
  • Clifford Krolick
    commented 2021-02-22 08:10:02 -0500
    Is Governor Mills and CMP Honeymoon Finally Over?

    Touting the advantages of the CMP Clean Energy Corridor and singing their praises, maybe Janet Mills has finally awoken to the reality that CMP’s Clean Energy Connect offers little in the way of supporting or reaching her and Maines’goal of a clean energy future.

    Since she’s taken office, other then supporting CMP, she’s been remarkably silent on the fact that CMP’s utility rating has been the worst in the nation with no sign of improvement. CMP is privately owned by foreign interests and traded on the Stock Exchange. The only incentive for investors and owners is to increase their portfolio’s value, leaving no financial space or interest to reach Maines’ clean energy goal.

    This is why CMP has plenty of money for promoting their Clean Energy Corridor and no money to honor all the renewable interconnection contracts that they have signed with numerous municipalities, individuals, and solar energy developers. CMP for years has been leaving a trail of broken promises, roadblocks and misinformation sending municipalities, solar developers and many clean energy job prospects for Maine people out in the cold. It’s high time for the governor to reassess the foreign, privately owned CMP and support the rapid transition of our grid to a local non profit Maine consumer owned utility through a low interest bond .

    Janet Mills efforts for Maines’ renewable energy future might be better served if she took a step away from CMP. The corridor has little to no support from the majority of Maine people. It will not bring us clean energy and impact negatively our greatest asset for job growth and our economy, tourism

    Parsonsfield, Maine
    207-625-8189
    42 Woodward Road
  • Roger Bubar
    commented 2021-02-22 00:31:09 -0500
    Maine is being swindled by a foreign company. We need to control our own destiny. Their misinformation campaign is a gross betrayal of our rights as Maine citizens. I feel we should rid ourselves of foreign interference and buy them out.
  • Clifford Krolick
    commented 2021-02-21 09:36:46 -0500
    It is time for CMP to clean up their act, keep their promises, and fix their many problems. Sadly they will not and if they do they will raise our electric rates way off the charts. Their interests are clear: increase profits to their investors and stick it to Maine rate payers. Best Resolution is to purchase all of CMP assets at a very low interest Bond by forming a nonprofit consumer owned and operated utility. This will save Mainers and the state Billions of Dollars . Look at Texas now, CMP can try to screw Mainers to pay the extra billions in upgrades, They CANNOT do that if we take it over asap
  • Sandra Howard
    published this page in News 2021-02-15 05:41:53 -0500